Catholic Bishop in South Africa Faults Critics of COVID-19 Vaccine

Bishop Victor Hlolo Phalana of South Africa's Diocese of Klerksdorp / Credit: Courtesy Photo

A Catholic Bishop in South Africa has reprimanded critics of COVID-19 vaccines for discouraging others from taking the jab, saying that dissuading others from the inoculation is doing them injustice. 

In a Tuesday, June 29 video message, Bishop Victor Hlolo Phalana says, “No one is forced to take the vaccine, but I think we are doing injustice when we discourage others from taking the vaccine.” 

The Bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Klerksdorp adds that it is wrong to discourage others from being vaccinated because “lives can be saved by this vaccine.”

“It is not a hundred percent guarantee but at least it will save lives. It has saved so many lives,” Bishop Phalana says in reference to the COVID-19 vaccine. 

On June 4, members of the Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference (SACBC) noted the low uptake of COVID-19 vaccines, and blamed it on the ethical and safety concerns among the people of God in the country. 


“Some people and groups have expressed a few safety and ethical concerns around the COVID-19 vaccines. These have caused a number of people refusing or expressing a reluctance to accept the vaccine,” the Bishops said in their statement.

Some of the concerns SACBC members highlighted included the duration of the production of the vaccine, the fear that the vaccine would change the DNA of those who receive it, and the claims that the jabs were being made from aborted fetuses.

The Catholic Church leaders assured the people of God in South Africa that research on the global pandemic was done faster and different “trusted” scientists in the country had acknowledged that the speed of development of the vaccines has been “a reflection of the level of scientific advancement that we are now at rather than that it was in any way recklessly rushed through.”

They also dispelled the fear that the jab will change people’s DNA, saying “The COVID-19 Vaccine is not made of DNA elements and therefore cannot change our genetic code.” 

Reacting to the claims that the jabs were being made from aborted fetuses, SACBC members said, “It is true that some vaccines including COVID-19 Vaccine originally included a protein sourced from a foetus but there is no evidence that current vaccines are directly made out of foetal tissue, nor is it true that foetuses were intentionally harvested to make the COVID-19 vaccine.”

More in Africa

In the June 29 video message, Bishop Phalana encourages the uptake of the vaccine saying that it is an answered prayer. 

“We were praying for a solution and the Lord gave us scientists, medical doctors, who have come up with a vaccine,” he said.

Bishop Phalana goes on to recognize that South Africans are going through “a very difficult time” because of the pandemic and the regulations instituted to control its spread. 

On June 27, South Africa’s President Cyril Ramaphosa announced stringent measures to contain the spread of COVID-19. 

Some of the measures include the prohibition of all indoors and outdoor gatherings except for funerals, a ban on travel in and out of Gauteng Province – reported epicentre of the disease – the institution of a 9 p.m. and 4 a.m. curfew and the closure of all schools in the country, among other restrictions. 


Bishop Phalana says the restriction on religious gatherings will be tough for many Christians “as we are not going to be able to worship together.”

Amid the challenge, the South African Bishop encourages the people of God to continue praying at home and to develop a family spirituality.

“A family is a domestic church, continue to pray at home,” he says, adding that the leadership of the church “will try to send prayers to you through social media.”

He also encourages the faithful to “hold on to the spirit of solidarity” by supporting the needy members of the society.

“Let us see the needs of our neighbors and see what we can do for them. Let us continue to support our sick, to the best of our ability to support those who mourn and those who are going through a very difficult period in their lives,” Bishop Phalana says in his June 29 video message.

(Story continues below)

Magdalene Kahiu is a Kenyan journalist with passion in Church communication. She holds a Degree in Social Communications from the Catholic University of Eastern Africa (CUEA). Currently, she works as a journalist for ACI Africa.